Doxa
Sign in

I Have Decided

Scot McKnight ·

Read on Substack
Summary
Doxa Score No concerns found

McKnight reviews former pastor Jeff Mikels' book Evangelical Idolatry. He commends it as a candid account of pastors' failure to disciple congregations against Christian nationalism and conservative cultural idols. He agrees with Mikels' broader, Jesus-centered view of the gospel, in which Paul and Jesus preach the same good news, and he criticizes an evangelicalism that reduces Jesus to a role in a Reformation reading of Romans.

Reviewed

Its text teaches none of the positions Doxa lists.

  • Pastors should disciple their churches into a theopolitical discipleship that conforms to Jesus' kingdom vision, which is the gospel, and failing to do so is a failure of complicity.

  • Many American congregations now hold a majority of Christian nationalists or semi-Christian nationalists, and pastors are overwhelmed by the task of preaching a kingdom vision of the gospel to people who have taken on political idolatry.

  • Endorses a source· Jeff Mikels, Evangelical Idolatry: How Pastors Like Me Have Failed the People of God

    Jeff Mikels' book Evangelical Idolatry is valuable and worth commending, as it describes a real condition in parts of evangelicalism and will help struggling pastors.

  • Adopts· Jeff Mikels

    Some bedrock principles of evangelicalism are tied to conservative cultural idols, and others have long pointed this out, though silos keep the message from being heard.

  • Adopts· Jeff Mikels

    The gospel is more than doctrine alone: it combines right thinking, personal holiness, and social action, and brings the good news of the kingdom into present-day living.

  • The gospel should be framed in a Jesus-centered way, and some of Mikels' earlier framings of it were more Jesus-centered than his final definition.

  • Adopts· Jeff Mikels

    Paul's gospel was about Jesus and was the same good news Jesus proclaimed, contextualized for new audiences.

  • Many Christians today give Jesus little place beyond being the agent of redemption in a systematic theology built on a Reformation reading of Romans.

No comments yet.